Jeremy Borash is in the back. He talks about reading all of the feedback on social media. He transitions to an I Quit Match. He introduces The Cowboy James Storm. He asks Storm if he is ready for tonight. James says people call him The Cowboy but you can also call him the Star Maker as he made Gunner a star in the past few months and he also made Gunner's daddy a star. However, he can also break a star and he will do so tonight as he will make Gunner quit. Gunner will find out that God will cut him down. "Sorry... not sorry."
A video package plays showcasing the story between Storm and Gunner.
James Storm's music plays and he comes out first. He walks down to the ring and steps in. Gunner's music plays next. He walks down the ramp and enters the ring.
James Storm vs. Gunner in an I Quit Match
The bell sounds and James and Gunner are on opposite sides of the ring. They walk forward and meet in the middle of the ring. They talk to each other but James quickly throws a punch to Gunner but Gunner punches back. It's back and forth. James puts Gunner in the corner and goes for a punch but Gunner ducks and puts Storm in the corner and punches him. He hits him with a closeline and then smashes him with a series of right hands. Gunner whips him in the ropes but James hits him and Gunner falls back through the ropes. He hits the guard rail on the outside and then it falls on him. James exits the ring and stomps on the guard rail as it is on Gunner's leg. James then places the steel steps around and grabs the guard rail. He punches Gunner in the face and then an uppercut. Storm goes to slam Gunner's head into the steel steps but Gunner blocks it and tries for James' head but he blocks it. Gunner punches James in the gut and it allows Gunner to him James' head into the steel steps. James walks around the steps on the other side. Gunner runs up the steps and flies and nails Storm. Both fall. Gunner stands and grabs Storm and rolls him in the ring.
Gunner looks under the ring and grabs a trashcan full of weapons. He also grabs a kendo stick and brings it in the ring. Gunner stands on the apron but James stops him in his tracks and punches him. He then brings him on the top rope as he holds his head. He has him draping and then does a stunner type move. The refeee asks Gunner but he yells, "No!" James chokes Gunner on the middle rope and then sets him up for a catapult between the bottom and middle rope. Gunner yells, "NO!" James exits the ring and grabs two chairs from under the ring. He then grabs a third. He gets in the ring and smashes the top of the chair into Gunner's gut and then smashes the full chair onto his back. James grabs a trashcan lid but drops it and stomps on Gunner.
James gets Gunner up and knees him in the gut and then hits a closeline. The referee asks Gunner and he yells, "Never." James grabs a cookie sheet and smashes it over Gunner's back. Gunner crawls to the corner. James tells him to, "Give it up." James then chokes Gunner. James gets him up and whips him into the corner. Gunner bounces out for a closeline but James kicks him. It doesn't stop Gunner though as he grabs James and whips him in the corner. He smashes him and then whips him in the ropes and hits a running knee. The referee asks James and he says, "No."
Gunner grabs the trash can lid and hits James in the head with it as the crowd chants, "AJ Styles." James grabs a lid and hits Gunner. They go back and forth. Gunner falls but grabs a trashcan and hits James in the head with it as he bounces off the ropes. Gunner climbs the corner and hits a diving headbutt. The referee asks James but he states, "No." James gets up in the corner. Gunner runs to him for a spear but James moves and Gunner hits the steel post shoulder first. James exits the ring and runs to Gunner and hits him in the head as he is lying there motionless. James walks up the steps and grabs Gunner from the corner. He pulls him through the ropes and hits a DDT on the steel steps. The referee asks Gunner but he isn't saying anything. James slaps Gunner's face as the referee asks him to get an answer. Gunner says, "No." James brings Gunner back in the ring.
James goes around the ring and looks under it. He grabs a beer bottle and gets back in the ring. He waits for Gunner to stand. Gunner stands and turns. James runs at him and hits the beer bottle to Gunner's head. The crowd chants, "One more beer." The referee asks Gunner if he quits. He slowly states, "No." Gunner's head is severely bleeding. James punches Gunner's open womb and then licks his hand. He then applies a Boston crab. Gunner yells, "No," as James has the submission. Gunner crawls to the ropes and grabs on. The referee tells him to release it. James does but pushes the referee down and then stomps on him. He grabs the referee's belt and then whips it across the back of Gunner multiple times. The referee asks Gunner but he says, "No." James puts Gunner around the ropes and whips him with the belt several more times. Gunner then talks to the mic as the referee asks, "Piss off." Gunner stands and turns but James hits him with the Last Call Superkick. The referee asks him and he states, "Never."
James grabs a piece of the beer bottle and rams it into the open womb and then a huge low blow. He stomps on Gunner and grabs him and hits him face first into the top turnbuckle. James grabs him and smashes him on another top turnbuckle face first. The referee asks him and he yells, "No!!" James does it again but it doesn't faze Gunner and then does several headbutts to the turnbuckle of his own. He fires up and goes after James with a closeline and then lifts him on his shoulders and spins and drops him down. Both are on the mat. Both slowly stand. Gunner waits for James to stand. He does but James goes for the Superkick but Gunner lifts him up and spins him around and hits him an F-5 type move and then does it one more time. He calls it Hanger 18! The referee asks James but he says, "No." Gunner grabs a chair and sets it in the middle of the ring. He then sets another chair in front of it. Both are unfolded. Gunner lifts James up on the top rope. Gunner climbs and goes for a superplex. James fights back though. Gunner falls off the corner but grabs a cookie sheet and hits James in the face with it. He then moves the chair over and grabs the steel guard rail that was used earlier. He lies it across the two chairs in the middle of the ring. Gunner climbs the corner and grabs Storm. He goes and hits a superplex on James onto the steel guard rail! The chairs break on impact!
Gunner gets on his knees and crawls over and grabs a piece of glass from the beer bottle. Gunner goes to James' head and yells at Storm to say it or he will cut him in half. Gunner starts slicing James' head but James yells, "I QUIT!" Gunner falls back. Winner: Gunner