- Johnny Gargano does an in-ring promo about how he lost the North American Title but he also talks about bringing it on RAW and Smackdown proving what NXT is all about. Tommaso Ciampa interrupts and proposes that Gargano is best whenever he teams with Ciampa. He offers to team with him so they can win the Dusty Classic and get an NXT Tag Team Title shot at TakeOver: New York. Gargano smirks and agrees.
- Aliyah/Vanessa Borne def. Taynara Conti/Xia Li by pinfall
- Dominic Dijakovic vs. Keith Lee went to a Double Countout
- WWE Women's Tag Team Champions Bayley and Sasha Banks show up in the ring to announce that they will be defending their titles on RAW, Smackdown AND NXT so they tell the women's division to step it up.
- Non-Title: Shayna Baszler (Women's Champion) def. Mia Yim by submission